My dad used to pause The Deuce every time Fat Mooney came on screen just to say "that guy's in everything." He was right, Law and Order, Boardwalk Empire, that shop in Times Square. Watching reruns alone on my couch tonight, 66 is no age at all.
Their story
E.J. Carroll was an American character actor and voice performer whose nearly three decade screen career took him from New York police procedurals to prestige cable drama. He was best known for playing Fat Mooney, the manager of a Times Square sex shop, in HBO's The Deuce, and Sheriff Victor…
E.J. Carroll was an American character actor and voice performer whose nearly three decade screen career took him from New York police procedurals to prestige cable drama. He was best known for playing Fat Mooney, the manager of a Times Square sex shop, in HBO's The Deuce, and Sheriff Victor Sickles in Boardwalk Empire.
Carroll was born on 21 May 1960. He made his screen debut in 1998 as Officer Fenwick in an episode of NBC's Law & Order, and went on to appear in three more episodes of the series through 2004, along with episodes of its spinoffs Law & Order: Special Victims Unit and Law & Order: Criminal Intent. Like many New York based actors of his generation, he built a steady career out of guest roles, and his television credits went on to include Blue Bloods, The Blacklist, High Maintenance, Pose and The Punisher.
He played Sheriff Victor Sickles in two episodes of Terence Winter and Martin Scorsese's Boardwalk Empire. His most recognisable role came in David Simon and George Pelecanos's The Deuce, set in the New York sex trade of the 1970s and 1980s, in which he appeared in six episodes as Fat Mooney, who ran a sex shop owned by James Franco's character Frankie Martino.
On film he appeared in Darren Aronofsky's The Wrestler, Kirk Jones's Everybody's Fine with Robert De Niro and Kate Beckinsale, The Night Listener, The Cake Eaters, The Winning Season and The Hungry Ghosts. He was also an active voice actor, voicing characters in the video games Grand Theft Auto V and Need for Speed: Undercover, and he played Dr. Scott in a concert version of The Rocky Horror Show. One of his last screen roles was as a stalker in The Mayflower.
E.J. Carroll died suddenly on Thursday 19 November 2026, aged 66, while on his way to a voice over recording session. His manager, Jon Mason of Mason-Lewis Entertainment, confirmed his death and said the cause had not been determined. His family planned a celebration of life in New York City in the new year. News of his death was reported by Deadline, Variety and TheWrap, which noted that he had still been working steadily in voice over at the time.
Biography adapted from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0) and news reports (Deadline, TheWrap, Variety). Wikipedia ↗

same, my mum called him "the sheriff guy" for years before she knew his name