mum just phoned me, proper upset, saying this was the man who wrote the review that made her actually laugh out loud reading the Post decades ago. I only knew him from that quote going round about a book being an embarrassment with not one redeeming virtue, dead savage. 87 is a good innings though
Their story
Jonathan Yardley was an American book critic and author who reviewed books for The Washington Post for 33 years and won the 1981 Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. Known for his frank, sometimes withering judgements and for championing writers early in their careers, he wrote around 3,000 reviews before retiring in…
Jonathan Yardley was an American book critic and author who reviewed books for The Washington Post for 33 years and won the 1981 Pulitzer Prize for Criticism. Known for his frank, sometimes withering judgements and for championing writers early in their careers, he wrote around 3,000 reviews before retiring in December 2014. He died on 20 November 2026, aged 87.
Yardley was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, on 27 October 1939 and spent his childhood in Chatham, Virginia. His father, William Woolsey Yardley, taught English and the classics and was an Episcopal minister and headmaster at two East Coast private schools; his mother was Helen Gregory Yardley. He studied at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, where he edited the student newspaper, The Daily Tar Heel, in 1961.
After an internship at The New York Times as assistant to the columnist James Reston, he spent ten years from 1964 as an editorial writer and book reviewer at the Greensboro Daily News, with a year at Harvard as a Nieman Fellow in 1968-69. He was book editor of The Miami Herald from 1974 to 1978 and then book critic of The Washington Star, where he won the Pulitzer in 1981. When the Star closed that year he moved to The Washington Post as book critic and columnist.
At the Post he became known both as a demanding critic and as a starmaker who brought attention to writers including Michael Chabon, Edward P. Jones, Anne Tyler, William Boyd and John Berendt. From 2003 he wrote "Second Reading", a series of essays reconsidering nearly 100 notable or neglected books, which included a sharply critical reassessment of The Catcher in the Rye and was collected as a book in 2011. He also wrote biographies of Ring Lardner and Frederick Exley, a family memoir, Our Kind of People, and edited H. L. Mencken's memoir My Life as Author and Editor.
Yardley was married three times; his third wife was the author and former Book World editor Marie Arana. His sons from his first marriage, Jim and William Yardley, both became New York Times reporters, and he and Jim were one of only two father and son pairs to have won Pulitzer Prizes.
His death was reported by The New York Times on 20 November 2026, which recalled a critic who believed that praise could be boring. He is remembered as one of the most influential and outspoken American book reviewers of his era.
Biography adapted from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA 4.0), The New York Times, The Washington Post, Nieman Foundation, Washingtonian. Wikipedia ↗
In their own words
“Not merely is it a textbook example of shoddy journalistic and publishing ethics; it is also a genuinely, unrelievedly rotten book, one without a single redeeming virtue, an embarrassment that should bring nothing except shame to everyone associated with it.”
Review of Joe McGinniss's The Last Brother, The Washington Post, July 1993
“Except for a couple of the books I've written, nothing in my career has given me so much pleasure as these reconsiderations.”
Closing the Second Reading series, The Washington Post, January 2010

that quote is from the Post, he really did not hold back