My mother called me the second she heard. She never calls.
Their story
This page was created 1h ago, as soon as Justin’s death was reported. The full story, with chapters and answers to the questions people ask, is being written now and should appear within the hour. You can already light a candle or leave a tribute.
Justin Evans was a 24 year old man from Christchurch, New Zealand, who had given up a promising start in club rugby to join a strict Catholic religious order on a remote Scottish island, where he was known as Brother Ignatius. He died in April 2026 after disappearing from the…
Justin Evans was a 24 year old man from Christchurch, New Zealand, who had given up a promising start in club rugby to join a strict Catholic religious order on a remote Scottish island, where he was known as Brother Ignatius. He died in April 2026 after disappearing from the monastery where he had lived for about two years, in a case that drew international attention and remains only partly explained.
Before he left New Zealand, Evans
grew up in Christchurch in New Zealand where he had been a student at the city's St Bede's College before joining the Sons of the Most Holy Redeemers, also known as the Transalpine Redemptorists.
He was also a club rugby player, and
played for Marist Albion Rugby Club
, which later remembered him as a member of its Colts and premier sides.
He moved to Orkney around two years ago
, taking on the religious name Brother Ignatius as a member of a small, traditionalist Catholic community.
Evans
went missing from Papa Stronsay's Golgotha Monastery on the night of April 11
, 2026, having last been seen
at the Golgotha Monastery on Papa Stronsay, Orkney, shortly before midnight on April 11
. Police Scotland launched a search, and the Diocese of Aberdeen said it had learned
with deep sadness of the disappearance and presumed death of Justin Evans, also known as Brother Ignatius, aged 24, a member of the Redemptorist community on the island of Papa Stronsay
. Weeks later,
a month later, on May 6, the body of Mr Evans was found in water off Stronsay
.
The exact circumstances of his death were never fully established. The order he belonged to said in a statement that
he is presumed to have drowned at sea, but that the circumstances of his disappearance and death remain shrouded in mystery
. Scottish prosecutors eventually closed their inquiry, with
COPFS confirming to a local newspaper that the case has closed
and that
no further action is to be taken involving the death
. He was buried on the island itself, with the leader of the monks there, Michael Mary, telling a local paper that
the young man's loss was the biggest tragedy for the order since they arrived in Papa Stronsay in 1999
. His home rugby club back in New Zealand paid tribute too, writing that it sadly advised of the passing of a beloved club member and 'terrific' young man, and his family held a memorial Mass for him at his old school chapel in Christchurch.
In the months since, renewed attention has come from a BBC documentary series, Highland Cops, which followed the police officers who investigated his disappearance and who later reviewed a personal digital diary he kept. Officers who read it said it contained no sign that he had wanted to leave the island or take his own life, and a constable who reviewed the entries described it as a record of a sensitive soul for whom his past weighed heavily. His death occurred against the backdrop of wider scrutiny of the small religious community he belonged to, which had already faced public criticism over its practices and its relationship with the Catholic hierarchy, though no connection between that scrutiny and his death has been established by investigators.
Biography adapted from News reports and the sources cited on this page; death reported by RNZ.

Same, mine texted just one word, 'Justin.'